|
 |
|
MDF
- The meat and potatoes of loudspeaker manufacture for decades
has been MDF (medium density fibreboard) which is made from compressed
softwood fibres held together with resin and wax. MDF is cheap
very machineable and is a reasonable material for building loudspeaker
enclosures.
Ok, that's whats good about MDF but whats not so good?
MDF is simply not stiff enough and does not have sufficient mass
to resist ringing. The main body resonance of enclosures built
with MDF is usually between 280hz and 400hz, this is in the power
range region and just above. Knowing how to brace or damp an MDF
enclosure is the key to getting decent performance out of this
material.
HDF or HD3
- The best all round material for building loudspeaker enclosures
is HDF or high density fibreboard.
It is however expensive but not prohibitively so, it costs here
in Australia 7.2 times that of high quality WR grade MDF. It also
has 1.6 times the mass of MDF
OK that seems like a lot more expensive but the sonic benefits
it brings must be heard to be believed. Comparing two pairs of
identical loudspeakers (right down to the wire and type of solder)
one pair built with 18mm MDF the other pair with 18mm HDF is a
revelation!
The MDF sounds glazed with a midrange humming that significantly
reduces resolution and rhythmic timing.
HDF by comparison is jet fighter fast, Piano decay for instance
is just incredible, the additional nuance and purity of sound
is amazing.
Enclosure Bracing.
- This is a very in depth and time consuming part of loudspeaker
design . Many designers simply link their enclosure walls together
with shelf bracing thereby raising the natural resonance of the
enclosure. This approach works reasonably well but it has some
problems, primarily because the negative enclosure energies are
not being dealt with they are simply being shifted to a higher
vibrational frequency, say from 300hz to 700hz for instance.
This approach is generally considered the way to go because it
apparently reduces enclosure colorations to an insignificant level
! NOT !!!! This is where Lenehan Audio parts ways with accepted
design practice.
For the past seven years we have been developing a proprietary
enclosure bracing technique we call differential bracing cancellation.
In short the Q profile or resonance patterns of opposing enclosure
walls are arranged so as to partially cancel each other out. We
do not lock together identical enclosure walls with shelf braces,
this can more than double the trouble at much higher frequencies.
Enclosure Damping.
- Dampening enclosures with the wrong or too soft a material is
a complete waste of enclosure volume and does nothing!
very stiff and massy enclosures require specific materials applied
correctly to specific areas.
We use hard bitumous layering and also Ply in various thicknesses.
Ply can be used for two entirely different functions, firstly
as a lamination to dampen some types of panels and secondly as
a brace to mechanically raise panel resonance without significantly
increasing mass.
One must remember that resonance is energy and energy cannot be
destroyed ; only diverted, converted or channeled.
Internal Damping materials.
This is also a critical area, we use a proprietry material we
call Stiky Foam in two different densities inside our enclosures.
Reducing internal standing waves and stopping reflection back
to the midrange diaphragm is of course important in stopping
mid and power range colouration.
|
|